Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Universal Health Coverage Expansion in Middle-Income Countries: A Systematic Review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22650131Keywords:
universal health coverage, cost-effectiveness analysis, health financing, middle-income countries, health insuranceAbstract
Background: Universal health coverage (UHC) has become the dominant organizing framework for health system reform in
middle-income countries, yet the cost-effectiveness of major coverage-expansion programs, and the financing architectures that
best deliver it, remain contested. Objective: To synthesize the empirical and methodological literature on the cost-effectiveness of
UHC expansion in middle-income countries, spanning country-level program evaluations and cross-national methodological
contributions on cost-effectiveness thresholds and extended cost-effectiveness analysis (ECEA). Methods: A narrative systematic
review of peer-reviewed literature on health, utilization, financial-protection, and cost-effectiveness outcomes associated with
national UHC expansion programs in middle-income countries (Thailand's Universal Coverage Scheme, Mexico's Seguro Popular,
Indonesia's Jaminan Kesehatan Nasional, Rwanda's Mutuelles de Santé, Ghana's National Health Insurance Scheme, Turkey's
Health Transformation Program, and multi-country Latin American and Southeast Asian evidence), together with methodological
literature on cost-effectiveness thresholds and ECEA. Twenty-two studies met inclusion criteria. Findings: UHC expansion
consistently generated substantial gains in financial risk protection across virtually all programs reviewed, with out-of-pocket
expenditure shares and catastrophic health expenditure incidence falling markedly following reform (e.g., Thailand's out-of-pocket
share fell from approximately 45% to below 15% of total health expenditure). Population health outcome improvements were more
variable and slower to materialize than financial-protection gains. Mandatory, general-revenue-financed models (Thailand,
Turkey, Malaysia) achieved substantially higher and more equitable coverage than voluntary, contributory community-based or
informal-sector schemes (parts of Ghana, Rwanda, and Cambodia), which faced adverse selection and narrow revenue bases.
Supply-side capacity constraints limited translation of insurance coverage into realized health gains in several settings, most
clearly in Mexico and Indonesia. Methodologically, the field has shifted away from the traditional 1-3x GDP-per-capita
cost-effectiveness threshold toward empirically derived, country-specific thresholds that are frequently lower, with extended
cost-effectiveness analysis emerging as a more complete framework for valuing UHC financing decisions across health,
financial-protection, and equity dimensions. Conclusions: UHC expansion in middle-income countries delivers robust financial
protection benefits and more heterogeneous health gains, with cost-effectiveness strongly conditioned by financing architecture
and complementary supply-side investment. Wider adoption of empirically grounded thresholds, extended cost-effectiveness
analysis, and more rigorous evaluation designs is needed to guide future benefit-package and financing decisions.
References
Lagomarsino G, Garabrant A, Adyas A, Muga R, Otoo N (2012) Moving towards universal health coverage: health insurance reforms in nine developing countries in Africa and Asia. Lancet, 380(9845):933-943, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(12)61147-7.
Atun R, de Andrade LOM, Almeida G, Cotlear D, Dmytraczenko T, Frenz P, Garcia P, Gómez-Dantés O, Knaul FM, Muntaner C, de Paula JB, Rígoli F, Castell-Florit Serrate P, Wagstaff A (2015) Health-system reform and universal health coverage in Latin America. Lancet, 385(9974):1230-1247, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(14)61646-9.
Reich MR, Harris J, Ikegami N, Maeda A, Cashin C, Araujo EC, Takemi K, Evans TG (2016) Moving towards universal health coverage: lessons from 11 country studies. Lancet, 387(10020):811-816, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60002-2.
Woods B, Revill P, Sculpher M, Claxton K (2016) Country-level cost-effectiveness thresholds: initial estimates and the need for further research. Value in Health, 19(8):929-935, DOI:10.1016/j.jval.2016.02.017.
Pichon-Riviere A, Drummond M, Palacios A, Garcia-Marti S, Augustovski F (2023) Determining the efficiency path to universal health coverage: cost-effectiveness thresholds for 174 countries based on growth in life expectancy and health expenditures. Lancet Global Health, 11(6):e833-e842, DOI:10.1016/S2214-109X(23)00162-6.
Tangcharoensathien V, Limwattananon S, Patcharanarumol W, Thammatacharee J (2014) Monitoring and evaluating progress towards universal health coverage in Thailand. PLOS Medicine, 11(9):e1001726, DOI:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001726.
Knaul FM, González-Pier E, Gómez-Dantés O, García-Junco D, Arreola-Ornelas H, Barraza-Lloréns M, Sandoval R, Caballero F, Hernández-Avila M, Juan M, Kershenobich D, Nigenda G, Ruelas-Barajas E, Sepúlveda-Amor J, Tapia-Conyer R, Soberón-Acevedo G, Chertorivski-Woldenberg S, Frenk J (2012) The quest for universal health coverage: achieving social protection for all in Mexico. Lancet, 380(9849):1259-1279, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(12)61068-X.
King G, Gakidou E, Imai K, Lakin J, Moore RT, Nall C, Ravishankar N, Vargas M, Téllez-Rojo MM, Ávila JEH, Ávila MH, Llamas HH (2009) Public policy for the poor? A randomised assessment of the Mexican universal health insurance programme. Lancet, 373(9673):1447-1454, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(09)60239-7.
Verguet S, Kim JJ, Jamison DT (2016) Extended Cost-Effectiveness Analysis for Health Policy Assessment: A Tutorial. PharmacoEconomics, 34(9):913-923, DOI:10.1007/s40273-016-0414-z.
Agustina R, Dartanto T, Sitompul R, Susiloretni KA, Suparmi, Achadi EL, Taher A, Wirawan F, Sungkar S, Sudarmono P, Shankar AH, Thabrany H (2019) Universal health coverage in Indonesia: concept, progress, and challenges. Lancet, 393(10166):75-102, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(18)31647-7.
Watkins DA, Qi J, Kawakatsu Y, Pickersgill SJ, Horton SE, Jamison DT (2020) Resource requirements for essential universal health coverage: a modelling study based on findings from Disease Control Priorities, 3rd edition. Lancet Global Health, 8(6):e829-e839, DOI:10.1016/S2214-109X(20)30121-2.
Stenberg K, Hanssen O, Tan-Torres Edejer T, Bertram M, Brindley C, Meshreky A, Rosen JE, Stover J, Verboom P, Sanders R, Soucat A (2017) Financing transformative health systems towards achievement of the health Sustainable Development Goals: a model for projected resource needs in 67 low-income and middle-income countries. Lancet Global Health, 5(9):e875-e887, DOI:10.1016/S2214-109X(17)30263-2.
Lu C, Chin B, Lewandowski JL, Basinga P, Hirschhorn LR, Hill K, Murray M, Binagwaho A (2012) Towards Universal Health Coverage: An Evaluation of Rwanda Mutuelles in Its First Eight Years. PLOS ONE, 7(6):e39282, DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0039282.
Alhassan RK, Nketiah-Amponsah E, Arhinful DK (2016) A Review of the National Health Insurance Scheme in Ghana: What Are the Sustainability Threats and Prospects? PLOS ONE, 11(11):e0165151, DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0165151.
Odonkor SNNT, Koranteng F, Appiah-Danquah M, Dini L (2023) Do national health insurance schemes guarantee financial risk protection in the drive towards Universal Health Coverage in West Africa? A systematic review of observational studies. PLOS Global Public Health, 3(8):e0001286, DOI:10.1371/journal.pgph.0001286.
Atun R, Aydın S, Chakraborty S, Sümer S, Aran M, Gürol I, Nazlıoğlu S, Özgülcü Ş, Aydoğan Ü, Ayar B, Dilmen U, Akdağ R (2013) Universal health coverage in Turkey: enhancement of equity. Lancet, 382(9886):65-99, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(13)61051-X.
Moreno-Serra R, Smith PC (2012) Does progress towards universal health coverage improve population health? Lancet, 380(9845):917-923, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(12)61039-3.
Nguyen KT, Khuat OTH, Ma S, Pham DC, Khuat GTH, Ruger JP (2012) Impact of health insurance on health care treatment and cost in Vietnam: a health capability approach to financial protection. American Journal of Public Health, 102(8):1450-1461, DOI:10.2105/AJPH.2011.300618.
Kaiser AH, Rotigliano N, Flessa S, Ekman B, Sundewall J (2023) Extending universal health coverage to informal workers: A systematic review of health financing schemes in low- and middle-income countries in Southeast Asia. PLOS ONE, 18(7):e0288269, DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0288269.
Horton S, Gelband H, Jamison D, Levin C, Nugent R, Watkins D (2017) Ranking 93 health interventions for low- and middle-income countries by cost-effectiveness. PLOS ONE, 12(8):e0182951, DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0182951.
Jamison DT, Alwan A, Mock CN, Nugent R, Watkins D, Adeyi O, et al. (2018) Universal health coverage and intersectoral action for health: key messages from Disease Control Priorities, 3rd edition. Lancet, 391(10125):1108-1120, DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(17)32906-9.
Karamagi H, Dovlo D (2015) Can extended cost-effectiveness analysis guide the scale-up of essential health services towards universal health coverage? Lancet Global Health, 3(5):e247-e248, DOI:10.1016/S2214-109X(15)70099-9.
